Transforming the entertainment industry: Time for a culture change
Written by Terence Rodia, Director of YOU Management
While the entertainment industry has long been associated with glitz and glam, behind the scenes, the industry hides a history of exclusivity and unfair treatment among its aspiring performers and industry professionals.
Gender inequality, ruthless and gruelling audition processes, gatekeeping breakthrough opportunities and diversity and inclusion issues are among some of the hard truths facing the industry. As such, it’s of little surprise to find that only a mere 2% of professionals make a living from acting, with two-thirds quitting after their initial year, as reported by Nature Communications. Still, with the industry bringing in 2.32 trillion annual revenue in 2022 alone, it’s fair to say that the entertainment industry is a pillar of the economy and maintaining and attracting new talent is essential to its survival.
So how do we stop losing potential talent after their first year in the industry and what can be done to create an inclusive culture to nurture the next generation of talent?
The dog-eat-dog mentality
It is not too far of a stretch to state that, historically, the entertainment industry has been viewed as a battleground – where only the ruthless succeed. A heavily competitive industry by nature, the fight for stardom is bred into performers from an early age, and they are often pitted against similar cast types in the bid to take a role. Given the large number of competitors, decision-makers can afford to be ‘picky’ in their selection process. As such, they often consider factors such as weight, height, appearance, likeability, and even personality when choosing talent. This sometimes results in socially unacceptable commentary being used in their decision-making, with performers often being told to develop a ‘thick skin’.
Even accomplished actresses like Meryl Streep have faced harsh criticism throughout their careers. In fact, Streep once recounted being told she was too ‘ugly’ for a role in King Kong during a 1975 audition. Instances such as these are a mere drop in the ocean of brutal comments to which performers are exposed to – ultimately discouraging talented individuals from continuing in the industry, and potentially robbing it of future stars like Streep.
A boys’ club
In addition to the cutthroat atmosphere, the industry has also been renowned for its equal opportunity and inclusion issues, not only in its performers but also in its directorial roles.
Despite notable successes by female directors in recent years, gender disparity remains a significant issue in the entertainment industry. In fact, the latest report from the Centre for the Study of Women in Television and Film, criticises the entertainment industry’s inclusion efforts, marking them as merely ‘performative’ and ineffective in fostering real change.
For instance, films like Barbie and Cocaine Bear, were both directed by women and have achieved astronomical critical and commercial success. However, despite their success, a study by the Centre for the Study of Women in Television and Film at San Diego State University, found that women still accounted for only 16% of directors for the top 250 grossing films in 2023, a decrease from 18% in 2022.
The lack of proper representation in all roles and positions, from casting directors to lighting and set design, excludes a wealth of potential talent and key demographics. This leads to inequality and can discourage women from pursuing careers in the industry.
Reluctance to adopt diversity and inclusion
The entertainment industry has long been associated with unfairly representing minority and underrepresented groups. In 2023, Statista reported that only 21.6% of lead roles of movies in the U.S are played by minority actors. However, promoting diversity and inclusion is crucial for the entertainment industry to become more dynamic and not only broadens audience appeal but also enhances cultural richness.
For instance, the Netflix series Bridgerton has achieved phenomenal success by featuring a racially diverse cast, challenging traditional period drama conventions, and generating significant financial returns. In fact, according to Netflix’s internal rankings, the first half of season three racked up 45.05 million views [total hours watched divided by running time] worldwide, equating to about 165.2 million hours of viewing time and broke the record for the highest single weekly view count for any Netflix series.
Similarly, in the theatre world, the musical ‘Hamilton’ has redefined Broadway with its revolutionary casting of historically white figures as people of colour, achieving sold-out performances and substantial cultural impact. In 2016, Hamilton also set a new record, receiving 16 Tony Award nominations and winning 11!
As evidenced by these two examples, prioritising diversity and inclusion can lead to both critical acclaim and commercial success, demonstrating that a more inclusive approach enriches the industry and resonates powerfully with global audiences. This, in turn, can attract a broader demographic and cultivate a more inclusive culture.
Providing equal opportunities
The entertainment industry must also ensure equal opportunities for all, including new graduates and graduates of not just the high-tier drama schools and backgrounds.
The industry is deep routed in its traditions from ‘break a leg’ to never speaking the last line of script before opening night, and it seems, its approach extends to its talent selection such as only welcoming and offering auditions to graduates of long-established drama schools.
It is not unusual to pick up a programme at a West End show, scan the cast page and read the same names of prestigious drama schools plastered across the resumes. While there is no doubt that talent from these establishments provides a certain level of calibre, such an approach can exclude a vast pool of potential performers who may lack professional training or industry connections but possess immense raw talent and fresh perspectives.
By perpetuating a cycle that prioritises the already privileged, the industry risks stifling innovation and failing to nurture the next generation of performers.
Open auditions and working with educational establishments [of all sizes and reputations] is a strategic tool for discovering and promoting amateur talent. Not only can this breathe new life into the field, but it also fosters a more diverse and dynamic landscape that reflects a wider range of voices and experiences. This shift is not merely a moral imperative but a strategic one, ensuring that the entertainment world remains vibrant, relevant, and inclusive for all.
Last call – A call for change
To foster a more inclusive and supportive environment, the entertainment industry must prioritise nurturing prospective talent and incorporating equal opportunities for all including underrepresented groups, genders, backgrounds and graduates. By breaking away from the dog-eat-dog mentality and showcasing the industry as a welcoming, encouraging for all and a prosperous career path, the entertainment sector can unlock a wealth of talent and ensure its continued cultural impact for generations to come.
The transformation of the industry into a more inclusive and nurturing space is not just a moral imperative but a practical one, ensuring its longevity and relevance in an increasingly diverse world.