Forget The Q4 Advertising Rule: New Data Reveals When Brands Really Get Their Best Returns
Brands automatically reserving their biggest advertising budgets and strongest creative campaigns for the final quarter of the year could be missing more profitable opportunities, according to new analysis of almost 168,000 Meta video ads.
Research from creator marketing platform Billo found that just five of 13 product categories achieved their highest return on advertising spend (ROAS) during the traditional Q4 shopping period.
Instead, peak performance was scattered across seven different months, suggesting creative and marketing teams may need to think more carefully about when they deploy their best campaigns rather than relying on the traditional Christmas and Black Friday advertising calendar.
Home & Garden, Apparel & Accessories and Software brands, for example, recorded their highest returns in July 2025.
Sporting Goods and Services performed best in September, while Electronics didn’t reach its peak until May 2026.
Perhaps most surprisingly, Baby & Toddler produced the highest individual return recorded across any category – $5.83 in purchase value for every advertising dollar spent – in January.
Is The Q4 Advertising Rush Right For Every Brand?
The findings challenge one of the most established assumptions in digital advertising: that the final months of the year should automatically command the biggest budgets and most important creative.
Billo co-founder and CEO Donatas Smailys said:
“You can watch thousands of campaigns and see the same mistake every year. Gift categories made Q4 look like the answer for everyone, so brands whose real peak is July or May just borrowed the same calendar without checking their own numbers. Every campaign we’ve analyzed tells a different story about timing. A brand pouring its best creative into November when its category actually peaks in July is burning its strongest work on one of its weakest months.”
Billo analysed 168,398 Meta video advertisements placed between July 2025 and June 2026.
The company measured ROAS by dividing the purchase value generated by each campaign by its advertising spend.
The resulting data reveals dramatically different peak periods depending on what brands are selling.
When Advertising Delivers The Biggest Returns
Summer proved particularly important for several sectors.
Home & Garden brands achieved their highest ROAS in July 2025, generating $5.33 in purchase value for every $1 of advertising spend.
Apparel & Accessories also peaked that month at $4.77, while Software generated its strongest return of $2.06.
September was the standout month for Sporting Goods, at $4.76, and Services, at $2.88.
The more familiar November and December peak was evident across five categories associated more closely with gifting.
Food & Beverages achieved a peak ROAS of $3.07, followed by Toys & Games at $2.90, Business & Industrial at $2.69, Health & Beauty at $2.44 and Animals & Pet Supplies at $2.08.
But other sectors performed considerably better outside the festive shopping period.
Baby & Toddler peaked at $5.83 in January 2026, while Arts & Entertainment reached $5.67 in February.
Electronics produced its strongest return in May, at $5.01 for every advertising dollar spent.
Billo cautions that the Baby & Toddler, Arts & Entertainment and Electronics figures come from the first half of 2026 and therefore represent the strongest month recorded so far rather than a confirmed recurring annual pattern.
Strong Creative Needs The Right Timing
For creative agencies, in-house marketing departments and content creators, the findings raise an important question about campaign planning.
Producing great advertising creative is only part of the equation. Deploying that creative when consumers are most likely to buy could be equally important.
“The Q4 rules work for gift categories, since that’s where it was built,” said Donatas Smailys. “The mistake is applying it everywhere else, as if every category shops like a holiday shopper. The same blind spot shows up with clicks: a brand chasing whatever month gets the most clicks falls into the same trap as a brand chasing Q4. Both are optimizing for a signal that isn’t the one that actually pays.”
The distinction between clicks and actual returns is particularly relevant as brands increasingly use performance data to influence creative decisions.
A campaign generating strong engagement or click-through rates does not necessarily mean it is producing the strongest commercial result.
Billo argues brands should therefore examine their own historic ROAS before deciding when to concentrate advertising investment.
Should Brands Rethink The Annual Creative Calendar?
The research suggests businesses planning campaigns could benefit from starting with their own sales and advertising data rather than automatically building their year around the traditional retail calendar.
That could also affect when businesses commission new photography, creator content, social video and other campaign assets.
A Home & Garden brand whose strongest commercial period is July, for example, may want its major creative assets ready months before agencies traditionally begin preparing for Black Friday and Christmas.
The same principle could apply to electronics brands preparing for a spring peak or sports businesses whose advertising performs particularly strongly in early autumn.
However, Billo’s research also suggests businesses shouldn’t manufacture seasonality where none exists.
Services, Business & Industrial and Baby & Toddler did not demonstrate a repeatable seasonal peak across the available data.
For companies in categories without an established pattern, spreading advertising investment more evenly throughout the year could make more sense than betting heavily on one particular month.
“Every brand we work with already has the answer to when their season is, it’s in their own ad data,” said Smailys. “The mistake is looking at the calendar instead of looking at your own numbers. Once you build creative around your actual peak month, you’re feeding the algorithm exactly when it’s most likely to convert.”
Nearly $230m In Meta Advertising Analysed
The findings combine two Billo benchmark studies covering the second half of 2025 and first half of 2026.
The first-half 2026 research examined 88,329 advertisements representing $122 million in advertising spend.
View Billo’s first-half 2026 advertising benchmark data
The second-half 2025 report covered another 80,069 advertisements and $105 million in spend.
View Billo’s second-half 2025 advertising benchmark data
Combined, the campaigns generated $418 million in tracked purchase value.
Billo publishes its benchmarks twice a year, examining ROAS alongside metrics including click-through rate and hook rate across 13 categories.
The findings provide a useful reminder for creative businesses and their clients: there may be no universal “best” advertising season.
For some businesses, the most commercially valuable campaign of the year might belong in the Christmas rush. For others, the data suggests their biggest opportunity could arrive months earlier – making knowing when to deploy great creative almost as important as the creative itself.